Spreadsheets tend to fit a small team with simple, stable processes. An ERP tends to fit when several people, locations or steps depend on the same numbers and the copies start to disagree. There is no single winner; it depends on where the business is today.
No commissions · Public sources only · Reviewed by Ray Rasouli
Compare for my setup
Neutral answers from public sources.
Tell me about your setup and I will say what to weigh between Spreadsheets and An ERP.
A scripted guide for now. It does not store what you type.
Verdict by situation
Pick the line closest to your company. There is no single winner.
In this situation
Spreadsheets tend to fit, because they are flexible and already known.
When a few people own the files and the steps rarely change, a well-kept sheet is cheap and fast. The key is clear ownership of each file.
Size and scope
Getting started
Pricing model
Working together
Inventory
Linking processes
Built from each vendor's public pages. Last checked Nov 12, 2026. Facts we could not confirm on a vendor page are left out.
We earn no commissions.
Awesoon is not paid by any vendor or partner named here for a recommendation. We work with these tools, so we have no reason to push one.
What decides this is not file size. It is how many people and steps depend on the same numbers, and how much time goes into checking that copies agree. If month-end means chasing versions of a sheet, or stock counts never match the books, the cost is already there; it is just hidden in staff hours.
The hidden costs of an ERP sit around the licence. Ask about implementation, which some vendors state is not included in plan prices, and whether you will work with a partner. Ask what data migration involves: cleaning item lists, customers and open balances from your sheets takes real time. Ask about integrations with your store, bank and shipping tools, and about training. Spreadsheets have hidden costs too: manual rework, errors from copied formulas, and knowledge that leaves with one person.
Questions for any ERP vendor: what is included in the plan, and what needs a partner or add-on? How do we move our current data in? How do roles and permissions work? Can we keep using Excel for reporting? Questions for yourself: which sheets are the real source of truth, who owns them, and what breaks if that person is away?
There is no fixed size. The usual signal is time spent reconciling copies, stock that does not match the books, or one person being the only one who understands the file.
Often, yes. Microsoft states that Business Central works with Excel, and many ERPs export data for reporting in a spreadsheet.
No. Several vendors publish per-user pricing aimed at smaller teams, and Odoo offers a free one-app plan. The bigger cost is usually setup and data cleanup.
A 30-minute discovery call with Ray, then a neutral short list for your setup. No obligation.
With Ray Rasouli. No obligation.